SUBMIT ABOUT FAQ
PEOPLE COMPANIES VENUES
LOGIN NEW USER PRODUCTIONS
REVIEWERS SIX DEGREES
A User-Driven Site for Theater in Atlanta, Georgia
Victor Freeze [ALL REVIEWERS]
Companies Reviewed#
Georgia Shakespeare1
Average Rating Given : 2.00000
Reviews in Last 6 months :
REVIEWS

Amadeus, by Peter Shaffer
Surprisingly Unsurprising: "Amadeus" at the GSF
Friday, June 22, 2001
2.0
In a recent AJC article, Georgia Shakespeare Festival Director Richard Garner politely said that he has “never been surprised” by any production at downtown competitor the Atlanta Shakespeare Company. He meant that ASC’s conventional style hinders the creativity (and enjoyability) of their work. Though he didn’t come out and say it, he implied that because of the Georgia Shakespeare Festival’s comparatively modern “take” on it’s classical repertoire, their productions are fresher, closer to the moment, and more novel.

If the GSF’s current production of Peter Shaffer’s “Amadeus” is any test of that statement, it’s hardly true. Garner is correct in pointing out the predictability of the Shakespeare Tavern’s work. (It can be fun for the uninitiated, but tends to stale after several visits). However as we sat in the audience of the Conant Theater during the first few minutes of the opening night of “Amadeus,” my wife and I sighed as we realized we were in for a very familiar experience. I can sum it up like this:

The GSF has GOT to start hiring some new, different actors and directors.

My wife and I have been attending the summer festival since we moved to Atlanta about 5 years ago and while we enjoyed it so much early on, we’re finding more and more that the sense of “surprise” that Garner referred to is slipping away for us too. The actors in the company are good, but we see them over and over in the same kinds of parts. For instance, we enjoyed Tim McDonough so much several years ago as a crotchety old buffoon in “School for Scandal,” but have since seen him so often playing parts like this (he plays the crotchety old buffoon Rosenberg in “Amadeus”) that I know what to expect from his part as soon as he walks onto the stage. The same is true of Chris Kaiser (the villain), John Ammerman (the heavy), Kathleen McManus (the shrew), Allen O’Reilly (the sidekick), Brad Sherrill (the pensive leading man), and to an increasing degree Saxon Palmer (the passionate leading man) and Janice Akers (the queen). I wonder if these actors are getting tired of playing the same kinds of parts every summer.

We were really hopeful that “Amadeus” would be different. It’s a modern play, faster-moving and riskier. But under Karen Robinson’s mostly uninspired staging, it settles into a mild, even-tempered rhythm. Partly at fault are Ammerman (as Antonio Salieri) and James Andrew Butz (Mozart), who seem content to keep their characters at arm’s length, paying more attention to their speech patterns than to each other. This Salieri and Mozart, admittedly very complex parts, seem two-dimensional. The actors comment more on their parts than they actually “do” them. The bright spot in the evening was Jessie Andary as Mozart’s wife Constanze. Andary seems to understand the style of the play, balancing her performance between a classical artifice and a believable human heartbeat.

It’s possible that the root of our unrest was Robinson’s direction, which itself has a predictable pattern. Robinson plays things safe, and the results can sometimes be muddy. (With some notable exceptions. Her “School for Scandal” that I mentioned was crisp and funny; “Tartuffe” was naughty but tidy). But too often Robinson ignores the emotional arc of the story and leads her actors to simulate turmoil rather than engage it. Whether she’s directing comedy or tragedy, the result is sometimes uniform and uninteresting.

My wife and I were laughing a little in the car driving back to Douglasville where we live, because we feel like we “know” these performers so well after 5 years. Maybe that’s an indication that we need to move on to other theaters in the area. After half a decade with the GSF, I think we’re ready to be surprised again.

CLOSING SOON
BattleActs Fall 2019
Laughing Matters
Intimate Apparel
by Lynn Nottage
Lionheart Theatre Company
Safety Net
by Daryl Lisa Fazio
Theatrical Outfit
The Dining Room
by A.R. Gurney
Main Street Theatre Tucker
The Game’s Afoot or Holmes for the Holidays
by Ken Ludwig
Players Guild @ Sugar Hill
The Grown Up
by Jordan Harrison
Out of Box Theatre
The Nether
by Jennifer Haley
Theatre Emory
NOW PLAYING
Almost, Maine
by John Cariani
Centerstage North Theatre
Baby
by Sybille Pearson (book), David Shire (music), Richard Maltby, Jr. (lyrics)
Act 3 Productions
BattleActs Fall 2019
Laughing Matters
Daddy Long Legs
by John Caird (book) and Paul Gordon (songs)
The Legacy Theatre
Downstairs
by Theresa Rebeck
Actor's Express
Intimate Apparel
by Lynn Nottage
Lionheart Theatre Company
Midnight at the Masquerade
by The Murder Mystery Company
The Murder Mystery Company in Atlanta
Safety Net
by Daryl Lisa Fazio
Theatrical Outfit
Swell Party
by Topher Payne
The Process Theatre Company
The Dining Room
by A.R. Gurney
Main Street Theatre Tucker
The Game’s Afoot or Holmes for the Holidays
by Ken Ludwig
Players Guild @ Sugar Hill
The Grown Up
by Jordan Harrison
Out of Box Theatre
The Nether
by Jennifer Haley
Theatre Emory

©2012 TheaterReview.com. All rights reserved.